Printable Page US Ag News   Return to Menu - Page 1 2 3 4 5 6
 
 
USDA's Fertilizer Grant Costs 11/17 10:07

   Company Defends Fertilizer Grant to Dairies Amid Questions Over Costs and 
Volume

   A waste-disposal technology company leads a USDA grant recipient to produce 
fertilizer from dairies in Indiana and Kansas. The project is slated to receive 
roughly 20% of USDA's proposed funding but will produce less than 3% of the 
projected fertilizer production.

Chris Clayton
Farm Business Editor

   OMAHA (DTN) -- The company selected for a $116.9 million grant to turn dairy 
manure into fertilizer is defending its selection for USDA funding, arguing the 
two dairy facilities will recover valuable nutrients from livestock waste to 
produce a nitrogen fertilizer for organic specialty-crop growers.

   A waste-disposal technology company leads a USDA grant recipient to produce 
fertilizer from dairies in Indiana and Kansas. The project is slated to receive 
roughly 20% of USDA's proposed funding but will produce less than 3% of the 
projected fertilizer production.

   Using manure from two dairies -- one in Fair Oaks, Indiana, and the other 
from Lewis, Kansas -- Sedron Technologies will produce about 25,600 tons of 
finished fertilizer product that includes about 4,100 tons of nitrogen content.

   The product would initially target organic specialty-crop growers, offering 
a domestic nitrogen source rather than directly competing on price with 
conventional fertilizers used across the Corn Belt, said Lucas Reid, who leads 
Sedron's agribusiness operations.

   For Reid, a fifth-generation farmer from southeastern Idaho, the broader 
opportunity is recovering nutrients from dairy waste and returning them to crop 
production.

   "We got to continue to find ways to create value from some of these waste 
streams," Reid said, "and figure out ways to be able to reuse the pound of 
nitrogen twice."

   USDA last month selected the Sedron Technologies project, listed under 
Agriculture Project Holdco, to move forward in its Fertilizer Investment & 
Expansion for Long-Term Domestic Supply (FIELDS) $573 million grant program. 
Sedron was one of eight award recipients nationally. When FIELDS was announced 
last month, USDA said it would add roughly 1.08 million tons of annual 
fertilizer production.

   USDA announced approximately $116.9 million in grant funding toward a $360 
million investment in the two dairies and Sedron's fertilizer technology. While 
Sedron received 20% of the total funding, its two dairy projects will only 
generate less than 3% of the projected fertilizer production, based on finished 
product weight.

   USDA stated more than 80 projects were submitted under FIELDS, representing 
as much as $15.9 billion in proposed investments and more than $6 billion in 
grant requests. USDA determined about $3.5 billion of these projects eligible, 
competing for $573 million in funds.

   The planned fertilizer from the two dairies is a 16-0-0 liquid ammonium 
nitrate, meaning it contains 16% nitrogen by weight. At that concentration, 
approximately 25,600 tons of finished fertilizer would contain about 4,100 tons 
of nitrogen.

   By comparison, DTN Fertilizer Trends reported UAN32 was priced at $484 a ton 
last week. UAN32 contains twice the nitrogen content of Sedron's proposed 
product, though the two fertilizers would serve different markets.

   Glenn Smith, who was sworn in as USDA's undersecretary for Rural Development 
in late August, said in an interview with DTN that he didn't have all of the 
specifics on each of the eight projects selected for FIELDS funds. "I know that 
it is very much oversubscribed as far as the number of applicants and ranked as 
to feasibility," Smith said. He added, "We can get back to you with the people 
that did the analysis here on that because what you're describing to me doesn't 
make economic sense."

   Smith said the competitive selection process gave him confidence that the 
projects had undergone financial scrutiny. "I do know, given the level of 
competition that was involved in it ... I can't believe that the math wouldn't 
work out for the award recipients in that case," Smith said.

   Josh Sewell, a fiscal policy analyst at Taxpayers for Common Sense, 
questioned how USDA evaluated the economic viability of the dairy fertilizer 
project and whether the department's competitive selection process adequately 
weighed the costs against expected fertilizer production.

   "It's at least as designed. It's a competitive process," Sewell said. "If a 
project represents one of the top eight projects in this submission, then 
either you've got a really small pool of projects, or it's just bad criteria, 
or there's something besides. There's a thumb on the scale. It's got to be one 
of them."

   Sedron also has significant private backing. Ara Partners, a private equity 
fund based in Texas and focused on industrial decarbonization, bought a 
controlling interest in Sedron last April, committing $500 million of 
investment into the company. Sedron's main business focuses on breaking down 
municipal biosolids to produce electricity.

   A MARKET IN ORGANIC CROPS

   Reid said Sedron's immediate opportunity is supplying organic growers with a 
readily available nitrogen source. He described the manure-derived fertilizer 
as a neutral-pH product that can help replace inputs such as fish emulsions and 
plant-protein fertilizers.

   Those alternatives require mineralization before some of their nitrogen 
becomes available to crops, he said. Sedron's product supplies nitrogen in a 
form that plants can immediately use.

   "Our product is 100% plant available," Reid said.

   Sedron is targeting specialty organic production in regions including the 
West Coast, Southwest, Upper Midwest and Northeast. Reid said the value of 
those crops supports a fertilizer price premium while the company works to 
reduce production costs.

   Competing broadly with conventional fertilizer remains a longer-term goal.

   "Ultimately one day ... it'd be great if we were able to get our product 
into the conventional space and compete on pricing," Reid said.

   USDA'S FERTILIZER PRIORITIES

   Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins repeatedly criticized the Biden 
administration's fertilizer grant program for failing to deliver enough new 
domestic production, arguing the previous administration emphasized climate 
goals over expanding fertilizer supplies.

   When Rollins launched the FIELDS program in July, she said the Biden 
administration had prioritized a "radical climate agenda" and completed only 6% 
of its stated goal.

   "The Trump Administration's FIELDS program is solely focused on producing 
fertilizer leading to lower costs for American farmers and consumers," Rollins 
said.

   In announcing the eight selected projects in October, Rollins said USDA was 
redirecting money from failed Biden-era projects toward "financially viable, 
shovel-ready investments."

   In doing so, Rollins wanted projects completed before the Trump 
administration left office. Another key scoring criterion for the projects was 
that they had to show they already had off-take agreements in place to buy the 
fertilizer being produced.

   NOT MOVING THE NEEDLE

   Josh Linville, who tracks fertilizer markets for StoneX, said shortly after 
the FIELDS projects were announced that it "missed the mark" on what is needed 
to expand fertilizer production.

   "There's one that where it lists $117 million to afford a $360 million 
investment to turn manure into fertilizer and maybe it's a typo but it's only 
like 4,100 tons a year. That really doesn't move the needle."

   From a nitrogen standpoint, the U.S. also imports 5-5.5 million metric tons 
(mmt) of urea products. Linville said it would take a bigger finance package to 
build a nitrogen project to scale that would reduce the imports of urea. "Not a 
single one of these projects touches that."

   THE TAXPAYER INVESTMENT

   Asked about the return on the proposed federal investment, Reid pointed to 
domestic organic fertilizer production, nutrient recovery and rural jobs.

   The nearly $117 million federal investment amounts to approximately $28,500 
for each ton of annual nitrogen production capacity. That calculation compares 
the one-time federal contribution with a single year's expected nitrogen 
output, rather than the fertilizer produced over the facilities' operating 
lives. It also does not account for other products and services generated by 
the facilities.

   Sewell said the scale of the investment raises questions about whether the 
project meets USDA's economic viability standards for fertilizer grants.

   "It doesn't seem reasonable to think that this is meeting the economically 
viable criteria that is in that ranking process," Sewell said.

   BEYOND ANAEROBIC DIGESTERS

   Sedron's equipment operates after anaerobic digesters, which capture methane 
from dairy manure for energy production.

   The digesters leave behind a nutrient-rich material called digestate. Sedron 
takes that material and separates it into liquid nitrogen fertilizer, a 
concentrated solid containing other nutrients and recovered water.

   Reid said Sedron designs, builds, owns, operates and maintains its 
facilities under feedstock agreements with partner dairies.

   The process uses heat to separate water and ammonia from manure solids. A 
system called mechanical vapor recompression recycles energy within the 
evaporation process, reducing energy requirements compared with direct boiling, 
Reid said. The company then separates the ammonia from water and uses a 
biological process to convert half of the recovered ammonium into nitrate, 
producing liquid ammonium nitrate fertilizer.

   The remaining solids contain phosphorus, potassium, organic nitrogen, carbon 
and micronutrients. Reid said that material can be used locally as a soil 
amendment and fertilizer.

   Recovered water can return to the dairy for uses such as cooling cows, 
washing milking parlors or irrigation, reducing demand for well water.

   The investment therefore supports several outputs beyond the liquid nitrogen 
product, Reid said.

   USDA's support for Sedron comes as the department has suspended new 
guaranteed loans for dairy anaerobic digesters through at least the end of the 
year. USDA cited concerns about loan delinquency rates and underwriting 
standards "to ensure prudent stewardship of federal resources."

   Sedron's technology processes material after anaerobic digestion, and its 
proposed FIELDS grant is separate from the loan guarantee program. Still, the 
differing federal funding decisions raise questions about how USDA evaluates 
the financial risks and benefits of dairy manure-processing technologies.

   EXISTING PLANTS, LARGER EXPANSION

   Sedron already operates facilities at partner dairies in Indiana and 
Wisconsin, Reid said.

   One is at Curtis Creek Dairy in Fair Oaks, Indiana, with an annual 
production capacity of approximately 3 million pounds of nitrogen (1,500 short 
tons). The Wisconsin facility, near Green Bay, has capacity for approximately 
1.5 million pounds (750 tons) of nitrogen annually, he said.

   Each proposed new facility would cost approximately $180 million and have 
capacity to produce about 4.1 million pounds of nitrogen annually. Together, 
the proposed plants would add about 8.2 million pounds of nitrogen production 
capacity -- approximately 4,100 tons of nitrogen contained in the finished 
liquid fertilizer.

   Reid said Sedron aims to begin construction at both locations in late 
first-quarter or early second-quarter 2027. The company's target is to reach 
planned production rates by the end of 2028, supplying fertilizer for the 2029 
growing season.

   A readily available nitrogen source could help organic growers narrow the 
yield gap with conventional production. Lower production costs could eventually 
help make organic food more affordable, Reid said.

   Sewell also raised a broader concern about the beneficiaries of federal 
agricultural spending, arguing that government programs too often concentrate 
assistance among a relatively narrow group of recipients.

   "It might be time to rethink some of these investments and think about who 
are the actual beneficiaries of these programs," Sewell said.

   Also see, "Trump Administration Champions Funding for 8 New Fertilizer 
Investments," 
https://www.dtnpf.com/agriculture/web/ag/crops/article/2026/10/22/trump-administ
ration-champions-8-new

   Chris Clayton can be reached at Chris.Clayton@dtn.com

   Follow him on social platform X @ChrisClaytonDTN 




(c) Copyright 2026 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved.

For more free DTN information sent right to your email each morning - click here to sign up for DTN Snapshot.
 
Copyright DTN. All rights reserved. Disclaimer.
Powered By DTN